收藏本站
收藏 | 投稿 | 手机打开
二维码
手机客户端打开本文

Quality Assessment of Clinical Practice Guidelines for Integrative Medicine in China: A Systematic Review

YAO Sha  Wei Dang  CHEN Yao-long  WANG Qi  WANG Xiao-qin  ZENG Zhao  LI Hui  
【摘要】:Objective: To assess the quality of integrative medicine clinical practice guidelines(CPGs) published before 2014. Methods: A systematic search of the scientific literature published before 2014 was conducted to select integrative medicine CPGs. Four major Chinese integrated databases and one guideline database were searched: the Chinese Biomedical Literature Database(CBM), the China National Knowledge Infrastructure(CNKI), China Science and Technology Journal Database(VIP), Wanfang Data, and the China Guideline Clearinghouse(CGC). Four reviewers independently assessed the quality of the included guidelines using the Appraisal of Guidelines for Research and Evaluation(AGREE) Ⅱ Instrument. Overall consensus among the reviewers was assessed using the intra-class correlation coefficient(ICC). Results: A total of 41 guidelines published from 2003 to 2014 were included. The overall consensus among the reviewers was good [ICC: 0.928; 95% confidence interval(CI): 0.920 to 0.935]. The scores on the 6 AGREE domains were: 17% for scope and purpose(range: 6% to 32%), 11% for stakeholder involvement(range: 0 to 24%), 10% for rigor of development(range: 3% to 22%), 39% for clarity and presentation(range: 25% to 64%), 11% for applicability(range: 4% to 24%), and 1% for editorial independence(range: 0 to 15%). Conclusions: The quality of integrative medicine CPGs was low, the development of integrative medicine CPGs should be guided by systematic methodology. More emphasis should be placed on multi-disciplinary guideline development groups, quality of evidence, management of funding and conflicts of interest, and guideline updates in the process of developing integrative medicine CPGs in China.

知网文化
【相似文献】
中国期刊全文数据库 前10条
1 ;Instructions to Contributors[J];Chinese Journal of Integrative Medicine;2011年12期
2 Arthur de Sá Ferreira;;Promoting integrative medicine by computerization of traditional Chinese medicine for scientific research and clinical practice: The SuiteTCM Project[J];Journal of Integrative Medicine;2013年02期
3 刘慧敏;;Efficacy and safety of integrative medical program based on blood cooling and detoxification recipe in treating patients with hepatitis B virus related acute-on-chronic liver failure:a randomized controlled clinical study[J];China Medical Abstracts(Internal Medicine);2014年02期
4 杨宇飞;Understandings of the Three Stages ofMedication in Using Chinese Drugs toAlleviate Adverse Reactions ofChemotherapy[J];Chinese Journal of Integrated Traditional and Western Medicine;2004年03期
5 陈可冀;吕爱平;;From Chinese Version of Integrative Medicine to Globalized Integrative Medicine:Impression on the 3rd World Integrative Medicine Congress[J];Chinese Journal of Integrative Medicine;2007年04期
6 Jun Wang;;USE OF TCM PROVIDERS FOR CANCER PREVENTION EDUCATION IN COMMUNITY-BASED PUBLIC HEALTH[J];Journal of Integrative Medicine;2014年03期
7 王丽芳;;Treatment of cerebral palsy children by integrative medical sequential method:a clinical efficacy observation[J];China Medical Abstracts(Internal Medicine);2014年02期
8 Wen-jian Wang;;Enhancing the treatment of metabolic syndrome with integrative medicine[J];Journal of Integrative Medicine;2013年03期
9 ;Instructions to Contributors[J];Chinese Journal of Integrative Medicine;2013年12期
10 ;[J];;年期
中国知网广告投放
 快捷付款方式  订购知网充值卡  订购热线  帮助中心
  • 400-819-9993
  • 010-62982499
  • 010-62783978