| | | | | 论我国拒证推定规则的完善——还其推定之本来面目 | | | 王绍凯 | | | 我国《证据规定》第75条所规定的拒证推定规则没能够充分体现推定之基本特征,给予法官自由心证的空间过大,阻碍了拒证推定规则本身所具有的有利于实现诉讼经济等优势的发挥。《证据规定》第75条所规定的拒证推定规则应被还以推定之本来面目,并且其本身的运用不应使当事人之间的证明责任发生转移。
【作者单位】：中国政法大学 北京100088
【关键词】：拒证推定规则;推定;自由心证
【分类号】：D925
【DOI】：CNKI:SUN:XZYF.0.2008-03-038
【正文快照】：
一、拒证推定规则的概念及其意义“证据为正义之母,”其既是当事人证明案件事实的依据,又是法院认定案件事实和作出判断的依据。在诉讼活动中,大多数案件当事人能够通过自己的努力获得需要证明案件事实的证据,但也有少数案件中的一方当事人因对方当事人持有关键证据但拒绝提供 | | |
| | |  推荐 CAJ下载  PDF下载 | | | CAJViewer7.0阅读器支持所有CNKI文件格式，AdobeReader仅支持PDF格式 | | | | Something on the Assumption in the Chinese Rule of Refusing Testimony Assumption——Giving Back the Original Meaning of Assumption | | | Wang Shao-kai | | | the rule of refusing testimony assumption in Chinese "Some Provisions of the Supreme People's Court on Evidence in Civil Procedures" can not reflect the basic features of assumption and leave too much space to the discretional evaluation of evidence which blocks realization of its advantages such as benefit litigation economy.The rule of refusing testimony assumption in article 75 of "Some provisions on Evidence in Civil Procedures" should be given back the original meaning of assumption and the application of which will not transfer the burden of proof between the parties.
【Keyword】：refusing testimony assumption;assumption,discretional evaluation of evidence |
|
|